| Round 1 |
| 1 | Jay | Felix Hernandez |
| 2 | Tyler | tadahito iguchi |
| 3 | Ben | Carlos Delgado |
| 4 | Jordan | Aubrey Huff |
| 5 | Brian | Eric Chavez |
| 6 | Evan | B.J. Ryan |
| 7 | Mike | Francisco Cordero |
| 8 | Tim | C.C. Sabathia |
| 9 | Ahad | Jhonny Peralta |
|
| Round 2 |
| 10 | Ahad | Tom Gordon |
| 11 | Tim | Jason Schmidt |
| 12 | Mike | Scott Rolen |
| 13 | Evan | Mark Mulder |
| 14 | Brian | Coco Crisp |
| 15 | Jordan | Bobby Jenks |
| 16 | Ben | Derrick Turnbow |
| 17 | Tyler | Geoff Jenkins |
| 18 | Jay | Richie Sexson |
|
| Round 3 |
| 19 | Jay | Jorge Cantu |
| 20 | Tyler | Jon Lieber |
| 21 | Ben | Curt Schilling |
| 22 | Jordan | Pat Burrell |
| 23 | Brian | Rickie Weeks |
| 24 | Evan | Scott Podsednik |
| 25 | Mike | Vernon Wells |
| 26 | Tim | Jim Thome |
| 27 | Ahad | Matt Holliday |
|
| Round 4 |
| 28 | Ahad | Eddie Guardado |
| 29 | Tim | Cliff Lee |
| 30 | Mike | Bob Wickman |
| 31 | Evan | Mark Prior |
| 32 | Brian | Armando Benetiz |
| 33 | Jordan | Randy Winn |
| 34 | Ben | Zach Duke |
| 35 | Tyler | Brandon Webb |
| 36 | Jay | Todd Jones |
|
| Round 5 |
| 37 | Jay | Jose Valverde |
| 38 | Tyler | Mike Gonzalez |
| 39 | Ben | Benji Molina |
| 40 | Jordan | Joe Borowski |
| 41 | Brian | John Patterson |
| 42 | Evan | Freddy Garcia |
| 43 | Mike | Matt Cain |
| 44 | Tim | Ramon Hernandez |
| 45 | Ahad | Doug Davis |
|
| Round 6 |
| 46 | Ahad | Willy Taveres |
| 47 | Tim | Joe Blanton |
| 48 | Mike | Jeremy Hermida |
| 49 | Evan | Noah Lowry |
| 50 | Brian | Felipe Lopez |
| 51 | Jordan | Brett Myers |
| 52 | Ben | Chad Tracey |
| 53 | Tyler | Paul Byrd |
| 54 | Jay | Julio Lugo |
|
| Round 7 |
| 55 | Jay | Javier Vazquez |
| 56 | Tyler | Nomar Garciaparra |
| 57 | Ben | Jonny Gomes |
| 58 | Jordan | Raul Ibanez |
| 59 | Brian | Kevin Millwood |
| 60 | Evan | Jose Contreras |
| 61 | Mike | Prince Fielder |
| 62 | Tim | Sean Casey |
| 63 | Ahad | Placido Polanco |
|
| Round 8 |
| 64 | Ahad | Chris Ray |
| 65 | Tim | Jake Westbrook |
| 66 | Mike | Oliver Perez |
| 67 | Evan | Bobby Crosby |
| 68 | Brian | Shea Hillenbrand |
| 69 | Jordan | J.D. Drew |
| 70 | Ben | Willy Mo Pena |
| 71 | Tyler | Esteban Loaiza |
| 72 | Jay | Chris Shelton |
|
| Round 9 |
| 73 | Jay | Keith Foulke |
| 74 | Tyler | Jeromy Burnitz |
| 75 | Ben | Jermaine Dye |
| 76 | Jordan | Mark Ellis |
| 77 | Brian | Livan Hernandez |
| 78 | Evan | Magglio Ordonez |
| 79 | Mike | Ryan Dempster |
| 80 | Tim | Luis Gonzalez |
| 81 | Ahad | Erik Bedard |
|
| Round 10 |
| 82 | Ahad | Mark Loretta |
| 83 | Tim | Chris Capuano |
| 84 | Mike | A.J. Pierzynski |
| 85 | Evan | Craig Biggio |
| 86 | Brian | Brian Fuentes |
| 87 | Jordan | Brad Radke |
| 88 | Ben | Curtis Granderson |
| 89 | Tyler | David DeJesus |
| 90 | Jay | Jason Kendall |
|
| Round 11 |
| 91 | Jay | Dallas McPherson |
| 92 | Tyler | Kevin Mench |
| 93 | Ben | Jonathan Papelbon |
| 94 | Jordan | Jason Lane |
| 95 | Brian | Michael Barrett |
| 96 | Evan | Chris Reitsma |
| 97 | Mike | Jeff Weaver |
| 98 | Tim | Aaron Harang |
| 99 | Ahad | Carlos Silva |
|
| Round 12 |
| 100 | Ahad | Mike Jacobs |
| 101 | Tim | Jacque Jones |
| 102 | Mike | B.J. Upton |
| 103 | Evan | Brian McCann |
| 104 | Brian | Garret Anderson |
| 105 | Jordan | Brad Penny |
| 106 | Ben | Robinson Cano |
| 107 | Tyler | Kenny Rogers |
| 108 | Jay | Kelvim Escobar |
|